Be Excellent To Each Other

[vote:davpaz]

Now I am even more confused by that second note ??

WTF is Gos talking about?

A note you say, why yes I did!
But don't put me over the barrel.
A simple thing in truth it was,
A quote from Muppet's Christmas Carol.

The Mafia were taking a guess on Joans? or one of the secret roles can investigate & pass notes?

Right, sorry, but are there 3 note passers?

Edit 4 note passers.

Good lord, dear friend, your vote indeed was quite out of the blue.
Explain yourself, I think you must, what is lies and what is true?

You're bad. People should vote for you.

I have no idea ??!! I'm going to call it a day and go home now & think about this more tomorrow.

At the start we have





Nick was one of the good ones , there is 1 more good / 1 bad + we dont know if either of the hidden roles can pass notes.

So, we had 4 notes passed on night one, apparently? Or is DP's from today?

Davpaz is just saying he sent that one to Gos, ain't he? Revealing himself to be ... A NOTE PASSER!

Well DavPaz?

To avoid confusion, I'll say it plain,
as plain as plain can be.
The note was sent on night number 2,
As was sent by PM to me

Get with the killing. Of DavPaz. And stuff.

Any particular reason why we should off DavPaz ?

He's a baddy.

yeah, why not. [vote:davpaz]

To do what I explained five posts later. Selective posting makes you look susser than a suspect thing.

Based on?

It's an educated hunch.

So what do I do to make this work...

Stick it in here?

http://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/counter/quiet.php

Right, I'm rubbish at this aren't I? It's probably not much help that I tried to post yesterday, but the last vote was made before I finished. It's probably even less help that I would've voted for silent-whatever his name is at the moment.

Well he's not playing anymore, so who do you want to vote for instead?

I'm a bit confused about this note you say you received about me Gos. If you received it on night one, then obviously it doesn't contain anything gained from actual knowledge (although thinking about it, if I was mafia it would be a great idea), but looking back at yesterday, you completely ignored it, coming out and voting for Cras and not mentioning it when talking about the other note you received. How come it wasn't important yesterday?

Just vote for DavPaz.

So in the rules there are no characters with an investigative role (apart from the occasional genius elf) , why are you so sure of Davpaz ?

(I was originally thinking Grinch because of the rhyming but surely thats way to obvious ?)

Also I'd guess a wrong vote today is probably the end as we'd be down to 9 players tomorrow with at least 4 (or 5) baddies (assuming the mafia and the demented elf dont target each other)

Educated hunch.

Because I had convinced myself it was the mafia that had sent the note to me, the only reason I wanted you gone before was simply because you are too quiet in the game. The note could be telling the truth which is why I thought it best to share with the town.

Sharp Suit is also another quiet player which isn't helping the town. I'm just going to shut up today (someone made a comment yesterday that my talking too much was making it easy for the mafia to pick off the town).

Once the town has decided on who to lynch, I'll pop back on and cast my vote.

davpaz: 2 (Grim..., Bobbyaro)
joans: 2 (zaphod79, Mr Russell Sprouts)
gospvg: 2 (Trooper, Santanalian)

Not voted: 6 (gospvg, gazchap, joans, davpaz, sharp suit, goddess jasmine)

With 12 players alive, 7 votes are required for a lynch, and 7 nolynch votes are required to not lynch anybody.

http://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/counter/work.php

Who isn't voting for DavPaz? I fucking see you all

Come one come all, the choice is clear,
Unless you are a spaz,
His reasoning is bulletproof,
Grimch says vote Davpaz!

So... where are we today then!

We have Gospvg being dodgy and nonsensical as ever.
We have joans being quiet
We have Grim... sure that davpaz is bad, but not giving any explanation why. Come on Grim... give us something

and we have 2 votes for each of them.

Look at the past couple of days people, Gospvg has been all over the place! And he has either lied and hoped to get away with it, but got caught out, or really didn't read the rules. And he also either lied about a note, or lied by omission when he didn't say about the note in the first place.
FOS radars are pinging all over the north pole, he has to go, surely?

Give us a reason then!

No.

Basically

I believe unless we get a baddie on this vote the game is over - you saying do this and trust you makes me think your actually a baddie and think the same and are asking the town to remove one more person for you so that you win tomorrow

[Vote:Grim...]

Give me a reason to change my vote

Stop being dicks.

If my rhyming has proved nothing,
Then know it's not a whim.
Do you think I'd do this voluntarily?
I'm afraid I must [vote:grim...]

If that be true then your note to me about Joans is telling the truth

Hello Dead Thread - are you enjoying this mess ?

Look with the lack of talking by many people other than Gospvg we're basically at the crunch point and have no clue on whats going on (or at least I dont) - Grim... your argument for Davpaz is weak , if its really just a hunch try to tell us why you think he is bad - what has he done that made you suspicious of him.

Davpaz , I understand your affliction makes you speak in Rhyme - thats very grinchlike behaviour but I dont believe that we would have that type of restriction , can you (in proper rhyme of course) give us any indication on why you talk like this ?

Gospvg - I really think your confusing things at the moment which is not a good thing



Davpaz has claimed to receive a note - he has not claimed to be able to send one - I really think that of the 3 note takers the one saying Merry Christmas to people is the Elf , and the one saying someone is evil or to do tasks and become part of the brotherhood is the Mafia however without any type of communication or investigation role the note passing elfs are useless (unless the hidden roles use them in some way)

This game has been for me at least a test of wit and timing,
I cannot yet reveal the proper reason for my rhyming.
Suffice to say, my quest is very vital to the town,
And anyone who casts a vote for me is quite a clown

I've just caught up, and haven't got a goddamn clue what's going on here.

gospvg claimed at the start of day 2 that Cras was a baddie, apropos of nothing, which made me suspicious - even though that later turned out to be true (he was Scrooge, after all)

Grim... is claiming that DavPaz is bad, with no reasoning being given at all. DavPaz is now claiming that Grim... is bad, presumably retaliatory.

Is it confirmed that we lose if we lynch a goodie? Could Grim... be a bad guy, trying to push a lynch on a goodie who has stuck his head out so that the Mafia win?

DavPaz is clearly one of the secret roles, unless of course he's just rhyming because he loves words.

Lots of people (myself included) being quiet, too.

Please - if I were a baddy I'd clearly get you to lynch gospvg.

We've probably very nearly done so with the confusion.

I have to say I'm totally torn (and indeed am staying with Joans as a quiet one for the time being) for who to vote for, because I don't know how you can be sure Davpaz is a baddy without an investigation role.

Its not confirmed - we have 4 confirmed bad roles 3 mafia plus a SK

We have 2 hidden roles and my thoughts on that are one good and one bad.

*if* we kill a goodie today , and the SK + Mafia remove people overnight then tomorrow starts with 9 players with either 4 or 5 baddies (so the goodies will be potentially outnumbered)

Thanks I also did say one day 1 that Kovac is an elf