Gilly wrote:
Ok, Curio pushed for the lynch on Alberto, but given his role he cant have known anything and was obviously just going for someone and hoping they were another power role. (may I also point out I was the first to vote for Alberto and gave a good reason-his overreaction at the end of the previous day. Why does no one listen to my logic but listens to curios bloodlust?
)
From a quick skim of the thread yesterday, Malc was preaching caution about the Alberto vote. I skimmed the thread very quickly, mainly to see curios posts but the persistence of Malc drew my attention. Does this mean Malc was trying to save Alberto?
Mr Russell has been very very quiet, this makes me uncomfortable. Joins has been quiet but that is pretty normal, maybe he has a rubbish translator or something (do you use a translator Joans?)
I think I will [vote:Malc]
I am uneasy about letting others dictate the meeting since we have too many opposing factions and it all really takes is for someone to suggest a couple of names and all talk centres on those people from then on. I urge you to consider what I have said but to try and not be influenced by it. Instead, read back over the thread and try and reach your own conclusions. Our best bet to get the bad guys is to think for ourselves. Hopefully they all continue knocking each other off while we learn how to do that
Agreed. This somewhat supports a suspicion I had that the villains are going for quiet people to deny us information.
This suggests to me, though, that we may be better off voting for a quiet person to draw someone out and possibly reduce the number of targets the villains have.
The problem we have is that with most roles being effectively shared amongst several people (eg: we could have more than one Germanian), people sticking up for each other in thread might not mean they're bad'uns.
I would like to suggest that we hold out for a few days of no-vote or great caution, and demand that one German roleclaims, because that way we can get their information, but still have another member of the faction continue to investigate even if the roleclaimer is killed.
However, this depends on there being more than one German, and on more than one staying alive over several days. It also depends to a lesser extent on their actually gathering useful information, which isn't guaranteed.
So rather than recommend we do that outright, I'd like to ask the assembled members of council to consider it. What do we think? Worth the risk?