A thoroughly deserved 10/10 at Eurogamer -
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2010- ... iew?page=1Which helpfully says most of what I wanted to, but a few things are worth highlighting.
First up, this really is an MMO without the grind, if you've played WoW in the past, and I mean vanilla, Burning Crusade, or even Lich King - then you haven't played WoW, because Blizzard have rewritten the rules. It truly works as a game in its own right, it doesn't need to pad stuff out with endless grind or repetition, the game is now so big and so wonderfully put together, that it functions really well as an enjoyable and challenging ongoing experience - no longer are you asked to do the same thing thirty times over just to pass the time to the level cap.
Outland and Northrend were a massive improvement on vanilla, but Cataclysm takes it to a whole new level.
It still looks and sounds positively wonderful without requiring a nutcase PC to run (most laptops can make a decent job if it, any PC with a graphics card should be fine).
It's absolutely loaded with fun and humour, if you take the time to read the quest descriptions and speech, some of it is proper 'LOL' funny, although as with all Blizzard games, they do like the serious and dramatic stuff as well. (It even gets quite melancholy at times.)
As a solo experience game, it's entirely possible to play from Level 1 to 85 and never interact with other real people at all (although you'll want to buy and sell on the auction house), however, if you want to play 5-man instances or 10/25-man raids, you'll need to group up. This is best done in a friendly guild or you can simply use the dungeon finder groups. Quite a few 'normal' quests are designed to be more fun and/or require more than one player, a quick shout out in the 'General' channel will almost always yield someone to group up with just for a couple of quests.
(It's in instances and raids that the difficulty ramps up, normal 5-mans and raids can be tough, but 5-man heroics and heroic raids are in particular ruthlessly difficult but in an entirely fair way.)
PvP or PvE is down to a choice of realm when you roll your character, PvE means you can only fight players of the opposite faction by mutual consent, PvP pretty much makes the entire game a free-for-all, even if you're just out doing a bit of a peaceful questing.
It's never going to be everyone's cup of tea of course, but I think WoW gets a lot of stick from people who don't really know what it's about, have prejudices that make no sense, or played it five years ago to burnout and don't realise how much it's changed.
Me and my guild are on the realm of Frostwhisper (Alliance faction), which is a PvP server. Anyone fancies giving the game a try with a friendly face around feel free to give me a shout (a PM here to let me know would be the best bet).
I know there isn't much love for WoW here, but I think that's a genuine shame because BEEX is in a lot of ways a 'games forum' and most of you like games of various flavours, and I reckon WoW deserves to be given a chance.
10-day free trial here -
https://eu.battle.net/account/creation/wow/signup/(Works on PC and Mac.)