superdupergill wrote:
Ok so if Dave is innocent does that also mean that we know who else is innocent? I will fling my vote in...
[vote: Mr Dave]
Sorry if you are a good guy...
So if we are right, we will have seven players left going into the night, with two bad guy roles remaining? So worst case scenario we are left with 5 people, two of whom will be bad guys.
If we are wrong, we will have seven players left going into the night, with two bad guy killing roles plus a bad guy investigating role? So worst case scenarion we are left with 5 people, three of whom will be bad guys.
I'm a bit nervous.
Ok, at current, we have 8 People.
Possible options (Scum, BS, Town)
1:1:6 or 2:1:5
Kill me, you have
1:0:5 or 2:0:4, as BS automatically disappears.
If the scum kill someone who isn't BS you have
1:0:4 or 2:0:3
That is the situation you're looking at.
What gives me pause for thought is the absense of a second kill last night. The last thing they would've wanted was to advertise their numbers for an utterly pointless investigation, and that is what an investigation would've caused. I'm much more drawn to the idea that Hulk was targetted, and his hidden capability was fending off attacks from certain bad guys, but that's only supposition, but certainly a very interesting idea.
Right. Thoughts on people:
Craster: Is Iron man. Is also somewhat disappointingly targetting me. If it goes through, next time we meet, you'll not hear the end of it.
Mr Dom: I've seen three separate reasons to believe him safe. However, a large part of this has been Crasters behaviour toward him. Also, that he didn't even consider something I said as a threat toward him. If he'd been looking to preserve himself, I think he would've picked up on it, nothing in his behaviour says that he has. If he is bad, he's very good at behaviour control.
GJ: In ordinary circumstances, would be a safe bet as a townie. Reasons I don't think her as the BS come mainly down to that I would've been quite valuble to her dead last night. Offsetting that is that I think I may have given the game away yesterday as regards Owen, and he's certainly a better target if you know his role, so not by any means as conclusive as it should've been. Again, She'd usually be safe as regards Scum, but looking at day 2, JBR was actually fairly keen on killing Runcle, early on and didn't unsettle the charge when it got up steam, only hopping off once the majority had done so, I think he may have been a bit caught out there. And so the day 2 logic isn't entirely watertight.
LaceSensor: Cannot judge him because he's said _nothing_ all game except for a vote on an already rolled man.
This is a little annoying, frankly. If he is town, this has not worked to our favour. Should've worked on him earlier, but he
still isn't saying anything. About the only thing he has done is stood up for me and TRO, which did cause a bit of worry, as there was no reason to stand up for me at the time.
Me: If you look back both Runcle and JBR have tried to frame me as a bad guy. I got on JBR swiftly. I could've put up a defense, but I didn't. Given his importance, it'd have been worth a try. It's succeeded before. I could still be BS. But I'm not. Owen would've died day 3 had I been. I picked up on that during day 3 while investigating what I'd missed on day 2 with the advantage of hindsight.
Morte: All i have to go on is his role claim. It is more convincing that others, maybe. That aside
I've made SDG talk lots, I've made her work lots, there should be plenty there for you to make your own choices.
Bobbyaro: "I noticed a distinct lack of people on the streets last night, and a number of people seem to have boarded up their houses, sad times indeed." Kinda smacks of a false roleclaim. And As SDG points out, he is very defensive of Runcle. "Craster is Evil, Craster is Evil, Joans is the real Ironman. (Joans votes Runcle) Ahhhh Joans is Evil, but Craster is Evil. Ooh, Runcle is Venom or Spidey, Don't kill him. I'll vote for the Spider-Gaywood, instead for no reason, despite two ironmen having said Runcle isn't spidey. No I'll vote GJ. She's Evil. Not Runcle! Owen is the SK. he's trying to kill Runcle! DON'T KILL RUNCLE! I LOVE RUNCLE! He's so smooth and runcley". Bobby ain't smooth.
Oh, and I voted for him yesterday. He was the very last person to vote JBR, at the point it was obviously a done deal.
So, do you want to continue voting for me? Now is your chance.