Craster wrote:
Not unless you've got a better choice of target, and as I stated, any of the names on my list could as easily be a misguided townie as a bad guy, except Curiosity.
Except earlier you stated that you *knew* everyone on the list was mafia
re-read page 19 :
viewtopic.php?f=8&t=2091&start=540And despite the fact that you've been quick with every other comeback it took you almost 2 hours to come up with "oh my god - Zaphod has called my bluff therefore he's "misguided"" ?
And you still didnt reply to my earlier post which asked why you claimed i changed my vote when i didnt
I *dont* see a no-lynch as 'my side' of the argument winning - the town need to lynch , if we dont and curio isnt the SK or he's blocked we're in the same state as if we just lynched him at the start of the day.
Again - i dont want to go over the same arguments again and again (as we've done most of the day) - right now we need the night players to come in and make their mind up
To summarise (please correct me if i'm wrong) :
Your argument :
Curio is bad therefore must die *NOW*
He's a loose cannon and has as much of a chance of killing a townie as anything else *OR* he's actually mafia and is playing us all like a fool
My argument :
Curio is bad and must die *later* , the town has much bigger concerns (namely the cult and mafia) he can die at any point
The Cult and mafia want him gone because he's dangerous to them - in some ways he's more dangerous to them than the rest of the town because hes not as easily swayed.
For the town we want as many people as possible 'fishing' for the cult leader , otherwise by about day 3 - get your robes on cause the cult will rule the world :-)
So :
We kill curio - cult and mafia probably get stronger
We kill someone else and curio and the mafia target other people - thats 3 chances of hitting the cult leader - thats the best chance we have of stopping them.
We kill someone else - mafia block curio and kill someone else - we have 2 shots at the cult leader and the mafia 'waste' their block on curio
You do seem to have changed tune from your earlier "your scum" to just about everyone who opened their mouth - why is that ?