just had a skim read through and lots has happened [vote:unvote] for now as i re-read the lot of it and work it out.

But Trooper calling for a match up of him vs Malc...i don't know what to make of it, if Malc is a Romulan/Borg then we have a good blow, but what if it is the reverse and Trooper is, if he is the Borg then they could then have 4 borg votes tomorrow, would that be enough people defending Troopers position to swing it, would they make a push this soon in the game?

Just my initial impressions from skimreading it all though, so i may have gotten the wrong end of the stick? Anyone else with more time fancy telling me how i am wrong?

Ok then, lets make this interesting.

I am a civilian.

Ok then, lets make this interesting.
I am a civilian.

Why roleclaim this? It makes you an easy target for the Borg. Unless you want to be recruited, which goes against your win condition.

Nonsense. With Q out of the game, I think every single person can be recruited by the Borg. Given that they would be more likely to want to recruit power roles, roleclaiming as civilian actually makes you least likely to be a recruit target.

If he is a borg, and the borg recruited 3 nights in a row successfully, then that will be 4 borg (as you've said), up to 4 people could die tonight (Romulan kill/whorf kills an innocent so kills himself too/redshirt). Plus the person being spaced.

Leaves 4 borg and 6 others with 10 people in total, I guess that's exceedingly unlikely (Whorf aint going killing unless he is 100% sure).

so most likely 4 borg from 12 in total, having 1/3rd not voting for you means, you only need 2 people to belive you or vote for someone else.

Also, starting a post with: and then on the next line saying: is a bit

Malc

If Worf belms it up again, there won't be a redshirt death as well, so there's a maximum of 3 deaths. Although as you said, it would be unlikely for Worf to get stabby again unless he's sure, so 2 seems a more likely max.

Vote people, me or Malc.

If you were to ask everyone in here now what role they were, all of them are going to say civillian though aren't they?

If they're not a civillian, and they say their true role, then they are either a target for the baddies (if good) or going to get lynched (if bad), so it's the most meaningless statement you can make!

Malc

Star Trek TNG Scum - Day Three
VOTE UPDATE

mr russell: 1 (myp it)
kovacsc: 1 (nickachu)
trooper: 2 (Malc, Bobbyaro)
flis: 3 (Mr Russell, gospvg, NervousPete)
malc: 4 (Trooper, TheVision, DavPaz, Craster)

Not voted: 4 (flis, kovacsc, slightly green, joans)

With 15 players alive, 8 votes are required for a lynch, and 11 nolynch votes are required to not lynch anybody.

http://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/counter/


OK, so you want it to be between me and you, but flis is on more votes than you, perhaps she is the borg queen or romulan boss, someone more vital to you, so you want to make it between me and you, not between me and her..

[vote:flis]

Malc

Or, you don't want to vote me off because you know that doing that will out you...

Of course, if you're both well-meaning but ultimately idiotic civilians, it will tell us nothing.

Not true, it will show who has been going against 2 proven good people.

Everything is significant.

Not true, it will show who has been going against 2 proven good people.

Everything is significant.

How does knowing who was going against 2 proven good people, before they were proven good, help in the slightest?

Becuase the bad guys would have been going for people that weren't in their known group, maybe...

Becuase the bad guys would have been going for people that weren't in their known group, maybe...

It's the truth, and while it won't give any information right now, it will give information if either you or me go out the airlock.

That's the point.

However, accepting the more convulted option 2 as a premise, and the fact that she posted twice on day 1 and twice on day 2, each time once at the start and once later on to vote. Then it does seem dodgy behaviour.
Also a vote for Flis will find us out two things, firstly who she is, but it will also give us a bit more info on DavPaz. Flis voted for him on day 1, which means it is unlikely they are on the same side.

from trooper.

Wouldn't voting for flis give us more info on davpaz and flis rather than info on either trooper or on malc?

Im unsure. Trooper... what have you got to say on this? you'd prefer we vote off you or malc rather than flis?

Oh, ok, you narky sod.

[vote:trooper]

ha, just kidding

[vote:malc]

I'm still inclined to go with what Trooper says. He's made some very good points so far so I think we should Lynch Malc tonight.

But Flis is a GURL

You are clearly a gay.

Actually... I've just read back and I'm now changing my vote. [Vote:Flies]

Do you want to try that again, or are you Pteronarcophobic?