Be Excellent To Each Other :: View topic - Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time

Looks to me, we might want to just fix the ship rather than exclude anyone else.

I doubt it's the case, but who is most likely to be a cylon in hiding?

(Yes, I'm fully aware what the response is likely to be)

Mr Dave - unknown - you've been rather odd , but then you often are :-)

Ok, so do we just have to get down to 5 people?

Or.. is there a Cylon left who is hiding out?
It is possible that malc is a Cylon, and when my awesome list of scum was published, they realised how stupendously boned they were. they then hatched a cunning plan to pretend that Malc was one, offering up one of their number as a sacrificial lamb to buy Malc the credibility. It did mean they had to seduce-kill Zeppo to prevent accidents on Malc, and by not killing now, it looks like there isn't a cylon left, and what with Malc being so helpful and all, he gets a ride home & cylons win.

So, as it stands:

Military (not going on ):
Curiosity
LaceSensor

Scientists:
kalmar - leaf scientist (95% sure)
Mr Dave - Plant psychologist (100% sure!)
Mr Dom - I'm just awesome I am!
Squirt - PILOT & wheat specialist (95% sure)
zaphod79 - root scientist

Suss:
Malc - ???

So, my money is on Malc for the heave, and we are good to go I think

I investigated squirt last night, he is indeed the scientist pilot

Malc

Military win: No Cylons or psychos leaves on Sweet Chariot.

I'm for whatever the concensus is.

In that light, the military should go, leaving one more person to go.

Malc wrote:

I investigated squirt last night, he is indeed the scientist pilot

Malc

And of all the people thats the one which we could work out .... not that great.

My suggestion right now is that we vote for a no-lynch and get Malc to investigate each person in turn - he will either give everyone a clean bill of health (then we vote him off to be sure) - or will point us at the remaining cylon.

If he points at someone , we vote them out and they are *not* the cylon then we can assume that he is the cylon , he kills overnight , we vote him out the next day and still win ?

The negatives on all this are :

1) If there is an unspoken time when we need to be gone from here
2) If he does clear everyone we still need to vote him out to be sure

For the military win condition they dont need to go on the ship , so at the end its the military that i think should be voted out

Quote:

Military win: No Cylons or psychos leaves on Sweet Chariot.

So having the Scientists only on the ship gives everyone their win condition (once we're sure whos who)

Scientist/Military psycho win: You leave on Sweet Chariot.

Okay well right now is there anything to lose by having a no-vote , and having Malc investigate Kalmar 'overnight' (who is at the top of my list?)

I have the terrible feeling theres a Cylon left , however as a scientist *i dont care*

Quote:

Scientist/Military psycho win: You leave on Sweet Chariot.

Mr Military people its up to you.

If there is a cylon left, I do care, each night increases the chance that I'll get zapped. The way I see it we decide on one person to leave behind, the military volunteer to stay behind (or we vote them off, if it needs to be done that way) and we blast off to safety

Malc

Okay well right now is there anything to lose by having a no-vote , and having Malc investigate Kalmar 'overnight' (who is at the top of my list?)

Well whom do you want me to investigate then?

I'm still not sure it's the best idea though.

Malc

I am actually pretty chilled with most people, the only fos I have atm is at Zaphod, who claimed to have commented about being a root scientist earlier in the thread but that post isn't there. Could easily be an honest screwup tho.

I want to pilot the plane outta here

My vote would be on the two military and Kalmar, right now, with the non military first, just in case.

Author:	Grim... [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:07 ]
Post subject:	Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
That comms light is still flashing, you know. [playerlist] Curiosity kalmar LaceSensor Malc Mr Dave Mr Dom Squirt zaphod79 [/playerlist] With 8 players alive, 5 votes are needed to stop someone getting on Sweet Chariot, and 6 nolynch votes are required to just go to sleep.

Author:	Mr Dom [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:08 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
turns the radio on

Author:	Mr Dave [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:09 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Looks to me, we might want to just fix the ship rather than exclude anyone else.

Author:	Mr Dave [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:11 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Also: Ick. Mr Russ seduced me. I feel dirty.

Author:	Grim... [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:12 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
The radio squeals into life, causing you all to cover your ears. Then it settles down and starts talking about a way off the planet. Apparently there is a space-craft on an old military base called 'Anchor Cliff', and you are being urged to join the migration of people heading in that direction. Mr Dom peeks through one of Sweet Chariot's portholes. The sign on the ruined fence reads '...or Cliff [newline] facility'.

Be Excellent To Each Other https://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/forum/

Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time https://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=6142	Page 1 of 2

Author:	Grim... [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:13 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Mr Dave wrote: Looks to me, we might want to just fix the ship rather than exclude anyone else. That would be lovely, but it isn't a plant.

Author:	Mr Dave [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:15 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Obviously, I'm not going to be fixing it, what with being useless and all. Unless you have Emo plants.

Author:	zaphod79 [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:28 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Okay no kill means that either : There is a Cylon and they are going to play it cool to try and make it onto the ship There are no Cylons left. The ship holds 4 people plus a pilot (we have at least 3 claimed pilots with Lace / Curio / Squirt) however 3 people here in this group cannot get on the ship. If there is a cylon left they want to get on the ship The Military need to stop that. Everyone else just wants not to get voted off.

Author:	Mr Dave [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:29 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
I doubt it's the case, but who is most likely to be a cylon in hiding? (Yes, I'm fully aware what the response is likely to be)

Author:	Mr Dom [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:32 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Ok, so do we just have to get down to 5 people? Or.. is there a Cylon left who is hiding out? It is possible that malc is a Cylon, and when my awesome list of scum was published, they realised how stupendously boned they were. they then hatched a cunning plan to pretend that Malc was one, offering up one of their number as a sacrificial lamb to buy Malc the credibility. It did mean they had to seduce-kill Zeppo to prevent accidents on Malc, and by not killing now, it looks like there isn't a cylon left, and what with Malc being so helpful and all, he gets a ride home & cylons win. So, as it stands: Military (not going on ): Curiosity LaceSensor Scientists: kalmar - leaf scientist (95% sure) Mr Dave - Plant psychologist (100% sure!) Mr Dom - I'm just awesome I am! Squirt - PILOT & wheat specialist (95% sure) zaphod79 - root scientist Suss: Malc - ??? So, my money is on Malc for the heave, and we are good to go I think

Author:	Mr Dave [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:32 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
In order of safeness: Curiosity Squirt LaceSensor Malc Mr Dom zaphod79 kalmar

Author:	Mr Dave [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:36 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Mr Dom wrote: Ok, so do we just have to get down to 5 people? Or.. is there a Cylon left who is hiding out? It is possible that malc is a Cylon, and when my awesome list of scum was published, they realised how stupendously boned they were. they then hatched a cunning plan to pretend that Malc was one, offering up one of their number as a sacrificial lamb to buy Malc the credibility. It did mean they had to seduce-kill Zeppo to prevent accidents on Malc, and by not killing now, it looks like there isn't a cylon left, and what with Malc being so helpful and all, he gets a ride home & cylons win. Yeah, thhat was my convoluted thought earlier. I discounted it at the time, but I suppose the timeout made it more plausible. Still don't think we have a cylon left, but still got to vote out 3. (Particulary - the one cylon not accounted for is the pilot. and they have stayed well away from any pilots, even when there may've been a tactical advantage)

Author:	zaphod79 [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:37 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Mr Dave wrote: I doubt it's the case, but who is most likely to be a cylon in hiding? (Yes, I'm fully aware what the response is likely to be) Kalmar is probably top of my list , despite the talking on day 1 he has been pretty quiet since. I would say ditto for Squirt , except that Pilot Scientist is a 1-2 role , and he was the only person to claim it - we know we have one so cant see why we would doubt it's squirt (unless someone else wants to come forward and say its them) Curiosity is a 'known' good person. LaceSensor I think since we took him right to the end and he caved in with 'just kill me' is almost certainly as he claims. Malc - I think is probably as he claims and the final investigator (if so who did you investigate yesterday?) Mr Dom - pushed things enough around the lace vote to make me convinced that we were onto the wrong person , and really tried to highlight where we were going wrong - I dont think he could really be a Cylon but if he is he deserves to win. Mr Dave - unknown - you've been rather odd , but then you often are :-)

Author:	zaphod79 [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:40 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
If Malc is trustworth he could check out the people we have ? (if he then points to X as the cylon , we lynch them and are wrong - Malc kills overnight we can still kill him the next day to 'win' ?)

Author:	Mr Dave [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:42 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
zaphod79 wrote: Mr Dave - unknown - you've been rather odd , but then you often are :-) And when are the times I haven't been? The way I see it is that the people who took us to this point are the ones who should get on.

Author:	Malc [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:43 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
I investigated squirt last night, he is indeed the scientist pilot Malc

Author:	Malc [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:49 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Mr Dom wrote: Ok, so do we just have to get down to 5 people? Or.. is there a Cylon left who is hiding out? It is possible that malc is a Cylon, and when my awesome list of scum was published, they realised how stupendously boned they were. they then hatched a cunning plan to pretend that Malc was one, offering up one of their number as a sacrificial lamb to buy Malc the credibility. It did mean they had to seduce-kill Zeppo to prevent accidents on Malc, and by not killing now, it looks like there isn't a cylon left, and what with Malc being so helpful and all, he gets a ride home & cylons win. So, as it stands: Military (not going on ): Curiosity LaceSensor Scientists: kalmar - leaf scientist (95% sure) Mr Dave - Plant psychologist (100% sure!) Mr Dom - I'm just awesome I am! Squirt - PILOT & wheat specialist (95% sure) zaphod79 - root scientist Suss: Malc - ??? So, my money is on Malc for the heave, and we are good to go I think Well I think you are maybe pushing this a bit too far, you picked 3 out of 4 (but is it 4? I wonder if we would be told all the cylons are dead or not? maybe we just have to whittle this down to 4 people and leave?) cylons. Now that could be a brilliant guess, or excellent deductive reasoning, but it could be insider knowledge, and everything you are trying to pin on me is actually your own scheming idea... Malc

Author:	zaphod79 [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:49 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Malc wrote: I investigated squirt last night, he is indeed the scientist pilot Malc And of all the people thats the one which we could work out .... not that great. My suggestion right now is that we vote for a no-lynch and get Malc to investigate each person in turn - he will either give everyone a clean bill of health (then we vote him off to be sure) - or will point us at the remaining cylon. If he points at someone , we vote them out and they are not the cylon then we can assume that he is the cylon , he kills overnight , we vote him out the next day and still win ? The negatives on all this are : 1) If there is an unspoken time when we need to be gone from here 2) If he does clear everyone we still need to vote him out to be sure For the military win condition they dont need to go on the ship , so at the end its the military that i think should be voted out Quote: Military win: No Cylons or psychos leaves on Sweet Chariot. So having the Scientists only on the ship gives everyone their win condition (once we're sure whos who)

Author:	Mr Dave [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:54 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
I'm for whatever the concensus is. In that light, the military should go, leaving one more person to go.

Author:	zaphod79 [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:55 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Mr Dave wrote: I'm for whatever the concensus is. In that light, the military should go, leaving one more person to go. Who should be that missing Cylon , i do think theres one left.

Author:	Malc [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:58 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
zaphod79 wrote: Malc wrote: I investigated squirt last night, he is indeed the scientist pilot Malc And of all the people thats the one which we could work out .... not that great. My suggestion right now is that we vote for a no-lynch and get Malc to investigate each person in turn - he will either give everyone a clean bill of health (then we vote him off to be sure) - or will point us at the remaining cylon. If he points at someone , we vote them out and they are not the cylon then we can assume that he is the cylon , he kills overnight , we vote him out the next day and still win ? The negatives on all this are : 1) If there is an unspoken time when we need to be gone from here 2) If he does clear everyone we still need to vote him out to be sure For the military win condition they dont need to go on the ship , so at the end its the military that i think should be voted out Quote: Military win: No Cylons or psychos leaves on Sweet Chariot. So having the Scientists only on the ship gives everyone their win condition (once we're sure whos who) Not so keen on that idea to be honest,and I now see it's 5 people that need to leave, As a scientist my win condition has me on the ship. It's one that I hope to achieve. Assuming we keep squirt alive The military can stay behind, that means we just need to decide on one more person to stay behind too. Who's it going to be? Malc

Author:	Mr Dave [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 13:58 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Depends on how cunning you think they are. Malc if cunning. Kalmar if not.

Author:	Mr Dom [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 14:08 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Ok, just looked back at Malcs record to find the evidence that he is an evil cylon scum.. Exhibit A... On day 1, he pushed for Dr G... oh... Umm.. Exhibit B... During the LaceSensor vote rush, he voted for Joans... Oh.. umm... Ok, maybe, just maybe Malc is telling the truth. Either that or it's an extremely solid Cylon triple-bluff strategy from day 1... Well, even if there isnt a cylon left, we still need to dump one person. or.. if we amputate 3 peoples legs, would we get away with enough weight to take off?

Author:	zaphod79 [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 14:37 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Okay well right now is there anything to lose by having a no-vote , and having Malc investigate Kalmar 'overnight' (who is at the top of my list?) I have the terrible feeling theres a Cylon left , however as a scientist i dont care Quote: Scientist/Military psycho win: You leave on Sweet Chariot. Mr Military people its up to you.

Author:	Malc [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 14:45 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
zaphod79 wrote: Okay well right now is there anything to lose by having a no-vote , and having Malc investigate Kalmar 'overnight' (who is at the top of my list?) I have the terrible feeling theres a Cylon left , however as a scientist i dont care Quote: Scientist/Military psycho win: You leave on Sweet Chariot. Mr Military people its up to you. If there is a cylon left, I do care, each night increases the chance that I'll get zapped. The way I see it we decide on one person to leave behind, the military volunteer to stay behind (or we vote them off, if it needs to be done that way) and we blast off to safety Malc

Author:	zaphod79 [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 15:01 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Malc wrote: If there is a cylon left, I do care, each night increases the chance that I'll get zapped. The way I see it we decide on one person to leave behind, the military volunteer to stay behind (or we vote them off, if it needs to be done that way) and we blast off to safety Malc Why do you not want to do zaphod79 wrote: Okay well right now is there anything to lose by having a no-vote , and having Malc investigate Kalmar 'overnight' (who is at the top of my list?) Which i've suggested twice. If there is a cylon left then you had a chance to spot it last night and missed , you have a chance again tonight. The Military need to get rid of it to win. The Cylon needs to get on the ship to win. The Scientists dont really care , the Cylon is not going to kill them , as long as we have a pilot the Scientists get on the ship and fly off (trusting in Pilot Squirt) The Military (Curio and Lace) should be pushing to discover and get rid of the Cylon if theres one left ? I'm just going to sort through my root samples to decide which ones i'm taking. BTW if anyone wants to recall the radio message , I think we need to get out of here 'soon' otherwise there will be other people who want to get on this ship.

Author:	Mr Dom [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 15:29 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
I am happy to try a no-vote for a day to give Malc a chance to scan someone else. I am actually pretty chilled with most people, the only fos I have atm is at Zaphod, who claimed to have commented about being a root scientist earlier in the thread but that post isn't there. Could easily be an honest screwup tho. Kalmar, I am happy with as he was banging on about his leaves from the very start. But.. even if we spend the time & prove that we are all human, we will still need to pick 1 of us to stay behind.

Author:	Grim... [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 15:45 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
There are two gunshots from across the complex. As you run around a building, you see Curiosity taking a pistol from a dead body and tucking it into his trousers. He already has a pistol in his other hand. Looking up at your questioning stares, he simply says "She would have dropped us all to get on board."

Author:	Malc [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 15:50 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Well whom do you want me to investigate then? I'm still not sure it's the best idea though. Malc

Author:	Malc [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 15:51 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Malc wrote: Well whom do you want me to investigate then? I'm still not sure it's the best idea though. Malc Especially after that last incident... Malc

Author:	LaceSensor [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 16:17 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
I want to pilot the plane outta here

Author:	zaphod79 [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 16:31 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
Mr Dom wrote: I am actually pretty chilled with most people, the only fos I have atm is at Zaphod, who claimed to have commented about being a root scientist earlier in the thread but that post isn't there. Could easily be an honest screwup tho. I did post that i couldnt find that - although its probably been in my preview window and i've went back and changed it I mentioned it in my post that day : viewtopic.php?f=8&t=6110&p=437101&hilit=mentioned+it+in#p437101 Question for the gods - if we decide that the military plus one scientist stay and 'all' (presumably apart from that one scientist vote for it is that enough to end or do we need to vote out each day?) A few quick things : Do we all agree the military stay (so Squirt is the pilot for the ship) ? If so then one of these people needs to stay behind : " kalmar Malc Mr Dave Mr Dom zaphod79 " If we need to vote each person out then we could vote out a military person now , and Malc does an inspection overnight which would clear or convict one of the people to go on the ship. If we do need to vote people out then we need 2 nights to get the military out , plus 1 for one of us however if there is a cylon left then we vote the military out tonight , they do nothing , we vote out the military the next night they kill and get on the ship (Scientists who live 'win' - Cylons 'win' - Military 'lose'). BTW Military - are you even there ? should you not be taking part in this ? , its your win condition thats on the line and neither of you have posted ?

Author:	zaphod79 [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 16:35 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
LaceSensor wrote: I want to pilot the plane outta here Why ? , if you are a military pilot right now you want to stop the Cylons - nothing about getting out of here. Only reason right now i can see for having a military pilot is if Squirt was incapacitated. (and remember the possible cylon thats left is their pilot).

Author:	Mr Dave [ Tue Jul 27, 2010 16:36 ]
Post subject:	Re: Cylon Scum 6: Actual company this time
My vote would be on the two military and Kalmar, right now, with the non military first, just in case.